Shane Schaetzel tries to figure this out at his Real Clear Catholic blog:
What if I told you that the people who taught me that the modern State of Israel is the centerpiece of Bible prophecy also taught me that the Catholic Church is the Whore of Babylon? I’m not exaggerating. Back in my Calvary Chapel days in Southern California, I learned that the rebirth of Israel in 1948 started God’s prophetic clock. I also heard a pastor call the Catholic Church the “Whore of Babylon” in front of hundreds of people. At the time I didn’t see a connection. Now I do.
While I would be the first to admit that Christian teachers and preachers didn’t do their reputations any favours by being glued to their prophetic watches, the real problem of Roman Catholicism with Zionism of any kind is their concept of the priesthood, which Zionism (in conjunction with other isms) undermines. As I noted many years ago in my post Priesthood, Analogical and Formal: A Reply to Fr. Greg on the Sacrifice of the Mass:
Jesus Christ is the only formal mediator between man and God. That is the core message of the New Testament. By “formal” I mean the “official” agent who is capable of the task at hand, i.e., mediation. We can say there are other mediators. For example, Evangelicals frequently say that we are the only Bible many ever read. (And we are!) But that doesn’t mean that we are a mediator in the same sense that Jesus Christ is. It’s tempting to say that we are “secondary” mediators, but the term I plan to use is “analogical.” By this I mean that, when we present the Gospel to others (and I don’t just mean exclusively in a specific outline, but also by the way we live) we are mediators by analogy. Ultimately anyone who is led to God in this way must come to eternal life through Jesus Christ.
Unfortunately the Roman Catholic Church presents itself as not only a formal mediator between man and God, but the formal mediator, by positioning itself between man and Jesus Christ. It claims that no one can come to Jesus Christ except through the church, and that the church has the authority to deny that access if it believes that it is necessary to do so. Fortunately for everybody it has an elaborate set of rules and regulations to make application of that exclusion an exceptional event (although one longs to see it for the likes of Patrick Kennedy.) But that doesn’t change the church’s view of itself or its role.
You take away the whole concept of the priesthood in Roman Catholicism, which is a successor to the Temple Priesthood in Judaism, you put Roman Catholicism in a tight place. And Christian Zionism, which generally posits the rebuilding of the Temple in Jerusalem and the resumption of the sacrifices therein, definitely undermines any priesthood between Herod’s Temple and the present.
As I noted in Because Jews Are Smart: Why Antisemitism is Re-Emerging, irrespective of whether you have a prophetic watch or not, the need for the State of Israel is simple: the Jews have been reviled, expelled or killed in just about every place they’ve settled, in spite of (or more accurately because of) their overachieving ways. I’m not sure that many in Roman Catholicism are on board with this idea either, but we need to consider the fundamentals if we are going to achieve greater understanding.
