Design a site like this with
Get started

Liberals and Libertarians Can't Get It Together

A couple of weeks ago, in my article Strange Bedfellows: Liberals and Muslims I made the following statement:

The left, by and large, is a statist movement. Their goals are ultimately achieved through supra-national organisations, the EU currently being the most successful. (The UN is somewhat more complicated because of the presence of Third World countries in the General Assembly, which have the bad taste sometimes to express their own views rather than those of their liberal patrons.) Nation states and NGO’s are their transitional organisations, especially the former, who have the power to tax. They furnish employment for their advocates and dispense patronage for their client groups. Their ability to promulgate laws is, for them, the preferred method of defining morality. If it’s legal, for the left, it’s moral, and illegal is immoral.

This simple fact is underscored in Ed Kilgore’s (from the New Republic) post It’s You, Not Me on why liberals and libertarians are apart again these days, after a flirtatious relationship in 2006:

Well, you can say goodbye to all that. The new Kirby/Boaz study reports that libertarian support for Democrats collapsed in 2008, despite many early favourable assessments of Barack Obama by libertarian commentators. Meanwhile, the economic crisis has raised the salience of issues on which libertarians and Dems most disagree. And there’s no question that during Obama’s first year—with the rise of the Tea Party movement and national debate over bailouts, deficits, and health care—libertarian hostility to the new administration has grown adamant and virtually universal.

Intellectual antecedents notwithstanding, the simple fact is that the post-modern liberal looks to the state for the perfection of their agenda.  It’s that simple.  There are philosophical reasons for that, but the biggest one is patronage: without the state, most liberals don’t eat.  Libertarians have a fundamentally different idea, and papering it over with a common enemy (even one like the Religious Right which inspires such dread) doesn’t change anything.


2 Replies to “Liberals and Libertarians Can't Get It Together”

  1. Libertarians never flocked to Obama as much as they ran from Bush and the GOP, and now that Obama has shown his true colors regarding a change to Marxism, libertarians have only the 19th century libertarian Democrats to look to, those who followed Jefferson and Madison. It is a grand awakening of the old Democrats who wil rise out of both the Democratic and Republican Parties and support those who support them. See The Changing Face of Democrats on Amazon and


    1. It’s always been a source of frustration to me why so many Americans were so blind to Barack Obama’s nature as a true leftist. Even with the scanty record he ran on in 2008, if you looked at his voting records in both the IL and US Senates, his intellectual antecedents, his books, his pastor and church, everything in totality spoke of a very left-wing person. But Americans just don’t look at things like that, and if they do they don’t understand their significance.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: